Monday 30 September 2013

Three useful websites about the Alberta Oil Industry




The first is Athabasca Chipewyan First Nation’s press releases about their ongoing legal battles with the oil industry and the Alberta and federal governments. Their language is blunt and they are being ignored at every turn but the battle goes forward. They will eventually win because they are right. It is just a question of what will be left when they do.

The second is the Alberta Oil Magazine. What is instructive here is how serious the oil industry takes all its spin of the “responsible development” of oil resources. I am sure it becomes easy to believe all this when you are becoming wealthy from it and are surrounded by people who are in the same situation. Reminds me very much of all the self-congratulatory economists, bankers,  traders, and their  politician buddies, getting rich off subprime mortgages and all the related fraudulent investment vehicles. They too saw nothing wrong with insiders (not) regulating the finance industry, nor with being bailed out in 2008 by the taxpayer so that they could continue to make multi-million dollar salaries while individuals and pension funds lost a great deal of money, in many cases all their savings.

The third is an on-going series of interviews with Albertans whose lives have been irrevocably damaged by the oil industry aided and abetted by a provincial government who really seems to have no concern about individuals or the environment.



Harper government sees art as a propaganda tool




Interesting story of a Canadian artist. The small amount of federal funding for her and a Canadian NGO sponsoring her  20-city European tour of her art was pulled because she was concerned about climate change. 

http://www.frankejames.com/buy-banned-on-the-hill/

 

Tuesday 24 September 2013

An Irish radio documentary on Dr. John O'Connor and Tar Sands health issues

An Irish radio documentary on Dr. John O'Connor, the Medical Officer for Ft McKay and Ft Chip and the Health Issues in the area. It was produced this summer by Nicoline Greer, an Irish journalist.

Go to:

http://www.rte.ie/radio1/doconone/documentary-podcast-undue-alarm-canada-aborigines-john-oconnor-doctor.html


What happened to the Energy Resources Conservation Board (ERCB) ?





In my blog, I frequently refer to the ERCB. Well it no longer exists. While the ERCB never saw a tar sands project it didn't like, over the objections of local politicians, doctors, and environmentalists, its replacement does not even have a mandate to consult the public. Why waste time listening when you are not going to act on the public’s input anyway? That, as far as I can see, is the “Alberta Advantage” touted by the Alberta government.



The following is excerpted from an article by Megan Wohlberg in the Northern Journal, November 2012:

[In November 2012], Alberta's Progressive Conservative government took the first steps toward creating its promised single energy regulator for the province with the introduction of Bill 2, the Responsible Energy Development Act.

The bill, which passed first reading on Oct. 24, establishes a single regulator for upstream oil, gas, oilsands and coal development from the initial application stage to reclamation, replacing functions of the province's existing regulatory bodies, including the Energy Resources Conservation Board (ERCB) and Alberta Environment and Sustainable Resource Development.

Adam Driedzic of the Environmental Law Centre speculated the regulator's mandate will be "overtly to develop resources" through specific qualifiers around safety and the environment, whereas in the past, decisions would have been based on whether or not the project was deemed to be in the "public interest."

"The decision to omit the 'public interest' mandate is deliberate - the result of a lack of clarity around this term during stakeholder engagement sessions," he said. Instead, the regulator will be charged with following government policy, such as regional land use plans.

"The monster this government intends to create will be unchallengeable and unanswerable to the public or government, with no duty to consult with the public or even required to make decisions in the public good," said Rob Schwartz of the Alberta Surface Rights Group.

Schwartz noted that legislated standing rights for landowners within the Energy Resources Conservation Act have been repealed in the new bill. Instead, the regulator will decide - based on yet to be released regulations - whether or not to conduct hearings upon receiving statements of concern from people who may be directly and adversely affected by a project.

As well, decisions on appeals will now be limited to questions of law.


And who is the head of the Alberta Energy Regulator ?


Gerard Protti, Head of the Alberta Energy Regulator

 
Excerpted from an article by Andrew Nikiforuk in the Tyee, April 2013:

    The Alberta government has appointed the founding president of the Canada's most powerful oil and gas group as well as an active energy lobbyist to head its new energy regulator.
Gerard Protti, a long-time senior executive for Encana from 1995 and 2009, served as the inaugural president of the Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers (CAPP).

He is also registered as an active lobbyist for the Energy Policy Institute of Canada.
That lobby group, which disgraced senior Harper advisor Bruce Carson helped to set up (Carson served as vice chair), says on its website that it wants to make energy regulations more industry friendly: "Help design regulatory processes that aid, rather than impede, responsible energy development."

An update on the oil spill near Cold Lake in a SAGD operation



An update on the oil spill near Cold Lake in a SAGD operation that I mentioned in my account of our canoe trip in early August. I have learned more from a September 16 update by Barry Robinson on the Ecojustice website. Here is an abbreviated version of the update.
 
The Canadian Natural Resources Limited (CNRL) reported the first of four uncontrolled bitumen releases at its Primrose operation in northeastern Alberta 4 months ago. More than 1.4 million litres of oil have already been released, but the spills have yet to be stopped. Oil continues to flow, contaminating surrounding ecosystems and killing wildlife. To date 104 amphibians, 43 birds, 40 small mammals and two beavers have died in the oily mess and the death toll continues to rise.


 
CNRL states that the spills are the result of oil flowing up through one or more poorly sealed wellbores. The Primrose operation is a cyclic steam stimulation (CSS) process in which steam is injected into the ground at high pressure to heat and release bitumen deposits.

Meanwhile, the Alberta Energy Regulator (AER) says that the source and cause of the releases is unknown.
This ongoing spill isn’t the first time steam injection processes have caused uncontrolled releases to the surface. In the early 1980s, a Texaco oilsands pilot project suffered a blowout. Total E&P Canada had a release at its steam-assisted gravity drainage (SAGD) project in 2006, and Devon Canada had a release at its Jackfish SAGD operation in 2010.

This isn’t the first time a CNRL operation has had problems either. In fact, this isn’t the first time there’s been a problem at the Primrose operation: In 2009, a leak was reported at Primrose. In a report issued four years later, the AER said it could not conclusively determine the cause of the release. The report also indicated that the release had contaminated a groundwater aquifer in the area.

While SAGD and CSS in-situ processes currently account for about 50 per cent of Alberta’s oilsands production, that percentage is expected to increase dramatically in the coming years. And if recent history is any indication, that activity will only put more of Alberta’s wildlife, surface water and groundwater at risk.
That is why it is critical the AER strictly regulate oilsands extraction processes to reduce the chance of these all-too-common leaks and releases. 

In the wake of this ongoing spill, twenty-three environmental groups — with Ecojustice’s assistance — sent the AER a letter requesting that it conduct a public inquiry on the safety of oil sands CSS and SAGD operations.

The AER promptly denied that request, stating that: “CSS and high pressure cyclic steam stimulation have been successfully used as bitumen recovery techniques in Alberta for many years.” It also added that a public inquiry would “not provide any new information that may be able to support or guide regulatory change.” 

All the while oil continues to flow at the CNRL Primrose site and new oilsands projects continue to be approved.

It’s not right. And so, Ecojustice continues to work with Alberta environmental groups to determine a response to the AER’s failure to take this issue seriously. Stay tuned. 

- See more at: http://www.ecojustice.ca/blog/nothing-to-see-here-except-the-oil-spill-thats-been-going-on-for-four-months#sthash.U8FcVaFk.dpuf

Monday 23 September 2013

"Won't Talk about No" Joe

Last Friday, the CBC Radio program "The 180" broadcast an interview with federal Resources Minister, Joe Oliver, who, with other members of the Harper cabinet, is presently in BC promoting energy projects to BC First Nations.



Broadcaster Jim Brown asked Joe Oliver whether he would be willing to accept a "No" answer from the National Energy Board whose ruling on whether they will approve the proposed Northern Gateway Pipeline is expected in December. He replied that he was not going to discuss "hypothetical negatives".

Would he be willing to accept a "No" answer from the BC government?  He was not going to discuss "hypothetical negatives".

Would he be willing to accept a "No" answer from BC First Nations?  He was not going to discuss "hypothetical negatives".

Clearly the federal government is ready to cover its ears and hold its breath until it gets the answer it wants. I hope that Oliver's discussions with First Nations are a little more open than this.

Friday 20 September 2013

Day 11 and 12 Tar Sands Canoe Trip

Fri-Sat August 16-17           The Barge Trip South


            I get up at 4:30 as do most of the others and we start loading Sara and Ron's pickup at 5:30. Yesterday evening, a few of the group moved our canoes right beside where the barge is docked which helps. Tristan drives the truck and before 6 AM, we are all ready and at the barge. Ray is there. Sara is there, too, to see us off. Leonard, another local man, is going to act as co-pilot. He is building up his hours on board so that he can get his captain’s papers. 



All of us ready to load the barge. Photo from Brittany.

             We load first the canoes in two tiers, and then fire all the gear underneath. There is still plenty or room for us. At the back, there is a second storey cockpit with space for Ray and Leonard, and they stay up there most of the time. At the window which spans the front wall of  the cockpit, there is the steering wheel and a desk, only enough space for two people to stand or sit. Behind this are two bunk beds. Like most boats, space is used efficiently. In the cockpit there is also a propane stove. On the desk, Ray has lots of documentation that is required and he also  marks changes in the river on his detailed river maps. Ray does this frequently so that someone else- Leonard, or Ray’s son- can pilot the vessel. He reads the river expertly as it is always changing and so are the sandbars. Only twice in the whole trip do we get close to grounding on a bar and then just enough to slow us down a bit. It is an art to navigating the river. 

 The barge loaded with our gear




Sign on the Barge

 
            Ray makes some coffee on his stove after we get going. He also hands out some oranges and later a few beers although very few of us take him up on it. He also lets us use it to supplement our stoves when we are cooking or making coffee or tea. There is also a fridge on the main deck in a corner. He has a generator which he uses from time to time to keep the fridge cold and run battery chargers and a cellphone booster in the cockpit. Ray had hoped to be able to weld a bracket on the back of the boat to allow installation of two outboards with which to make the trip in one day. However, he did not have the time and so we will require two entire days for the trip. There is a little storage space with a plywood sheet as a door. There is a bucket in there as a toilet. There is also the deck beside the cockpit where the men can pee off the back. We do make one bathroom stop each day on a sandbar. It gives Willow her only chance too, to pee and poop. 

            The route we take is similar to our route north with one exception. The barge will not fit through the log  jam at the far end of Mamawi Lake where we entered it on the way north; instead of taking our canoe route, we travel out onto Lake Athabasca, into another channel called Cree Creek, and from there into the Embarras Channel and on down the Athabasca. It is longer than our route, but significantly shorter than taking the big lake to the mouth of the Embarras Channel. The lake is very calm as we cross it which takes about an hour.



            As well as operating the barge with which Ray mostly brings goods up to Ft Chip for people, he also is a ship builder. He built this barge and is preparing to build another bigger one this winter to replace it. He also works for Suncor in the wintertime even though, he too is disgusted with what the tar sands developments are doing to the environment. He has also just purchased the trap line from Larry McGinnis at Embarras Portage Trading Post. He is talking about purchasing the Trading Post as well as the McGinnis’ are selling out due to Larry’s ill health, although he says his wife has no interest in moving there. He is one busy guy. Fifty-ish, and with a large pot belly and an easy imp-ish smile, he moves quickly. He has proven to be a man of his word, and very meticulous in everything he does. His business card says “barge operator”, not owner, and he tells me that his wife and daughter are the owners. 

Leonard at the wheel

            There used to be more traffic on the river: six barges. Now there are only two. Ft Chip was a more happening place before. Besides destroying the fishing industry, the tar sands has pretty much destroyed the tourist trade. A lot of Europeans and Americans used to come here to fish, hunt or boat. Fewer and fewer come now. They go to less polluted areas. 

            Ray tells me that he will occasionally shoot a moose en route, but only if he has time to stop and butcher it. We do not see any moose on our trip. When we get close to the McGinnis’ place, Leonard takes over while Ray gets into the little dingy with motor that is tied behind the barge. He tells us that Larry had called and wanted him to drop in en route.  He catches up to us half an hour later. He has closed the deal to purchase the Trading Post as Larry has dropped his price. I can see the wheels turning as Ray plans his next move with the Trading Post. He has promised Larry and Cathy that he will maintain the museum, one of their prides and joy. 

            When we go by Poplar Point, Mark is near shore with a few other people. He waves, we wave, we yell and he yells, but we do not understand what he is saying nor, I guess, does he understand us. 

            At 9:30 PM we stop and tie up to a sandbar. Most of us get off to set up tents for the night but a few pitch tents on the boat. Ray asks us to be back on board for 5 AM when it will be light enough to leave.

            We are up at 4:30, before dawn, and leave at 5 AM. We motor through a lot of familiar scenery.  At Mile 70 (Mile 0 is Ft Mac and Mile 203 is Ft Chip via the main route: through the Embarras Channel out to Lake Athabasca and then across the lake), we stop on a big sandbar for our one bathroom and stretch stop for the day. Afterward Ray tells me that the island is unnamed and he is going to name it after me: Pivnick Island. He asks me to spell it so he can get it right. I have mixed feelings. After all, we just stopped to crap on my island!!

            We motor through a number of pumping stations and the Suncor “compensation lake.”  Ray is not  impressed the idea nor with what he sees. He is convinced that the spring floods will wash away the lower slopes and entrance to the lake and the entrance will be blocked with debris. Sometime during the afternoon, Alex takes over at the wheel. She keeps making good progress.

           We have our last supper together: another potluck buffet with all kinds of delicacies. We invite Ray and Leonard to join us.

                                                         Raymond Ladouceur, the captain

            Finally around 9, in the gathering twilight we arrive at Shell Landing at Mile 4. The four  of us who are drivers are boated across to Ft McKay by Leonard in the little dingh. It is less than 1 km upriver. We walk in darkness up the hill and out of town to a Band compound where a new building is going up. This where we left our vehicles. It is further than I remember but Kevin remembers it well. The gate is closed but unlocked, as Brian Durant had promised when I phoned him a few hours earlier. We start the vehicles and drive the 10 km or so south to the Bridge to Nowhere, cross it and then drive  north in what is a freeway with several turnoffs for different tar sands projects. We turn off for the barge landing also known as Shell Landing, and in the darkness I pull into a hotel with security  by mistake. A few minutes later we arrive. We load vehicles, sorting whose gear is whose. The canoes go on racks. Heather, Howie and I decide to camp and leave in the morning, setting up tents on the barge, where Ray and Leonard will also stay. Everyone else is off right away, and the trip is over. 



            I will be canoeing this route again next August. Anyone interested in info or in joining the expedition can contact me at elipivnick@ymail.com or 250-299-3007.